TheGuiltMyth
Copyright 2008 by Michael C. Tillotson, Esq.
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used
or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without
written permission of the author.
Printed in the Un
DUI/DWI
arr e s t s urv i val g u i d e :
TheGuiltMyth
by
MichaelC.Tillotson,Esq.
Word Association Publishers
Tarentum, PA 15068
Table of Contents
Introduction—Is this book for me? What should I get out of it?
p. vii
Fact vs. Fiction—The Truth About DUI
p. 1
INTRODUCTION—
IS THIS BOOK FOR ME?
WHAT SHOULD I GET
OUT OF IT?
Isthisbookforme?
If you have been charged with a DUI/DWI1, this
book could make a real difference in your life. It also
contains infor DUI/DWI arr e s t s urv i val g u i d e : TheGuiltMyth
Copyright 2008 by Michael C. Tillotson, Esq. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission of the author. Printed in the Un
DUI/DWI arr e s t s urv i val g u i d e : TheGuiltMyth by MichaelC.Tillotson,Esq. Word Association Publishers Tarentum, PA 15068
Table of Contents Introduction—Is this book for me? What should I get out of it? p. vii Fact vs. Fiction—The Truth About DUI p. 1
INTRODUCTION— IS THIS BOOK FOR ME? WHAT SHOULD I GET OUT OF IT? Isthisbookforme? If you have been charged with a DUI/DWI1, this book could make a real difference in your life. It also contains infor
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC This book contains valuable information that per- tains to every major step of the DUI legal process. It will tell you what will happen and what you will need to know if you
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth benefit from both. If by the end of reading this book you feel more empowered to play an active role in fighting for your rights, and feel less anxious about
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC all. I tell my clients that there are literally hundreds of potential issues in a DUI case.Reading this book can- not take the place of an experienced attorney with an in-dep
HerearejustafewcommentsfromMike'sclients….. My DUI arrest was the most frightening experience in my life. You explained every aspect of what I was going to endure in defending my case.You explained
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC agreement which,in the end,was a better deal for me. For this, I thank you Mr. Tillotson! –Hal L. I sincerely appreciate yo
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth Thank you for your knowledge, dedication, and per- sonal care with my case. –Elizabeth N. Please know that
CHAPTER ONE FACT VS. FICTION— THE TRUTH ABOUT DUI Driving Under the Influence (DUI) is one of the most common criminal infractions reported,but it is also one of the most misunderstood. Among the pu
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC the way the law should work. Being accused of a DUI is not a conviction. No matter what your situation is, if you have been accused of driving under the influ- ence, you have
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth wrong place at the wrong time. You have no right to a lawyer prior to submitting to DUI tests. Moreover, in a DUI you must give evidence against yourself or
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC Myth#6:“Anyattorneycanrepresentapersonaccused ofDUI.” This is like saying that it is fine to see a podiatrist for high blood pressure. Like medicine, law is an area where it i
CHAPTER TWO “WHAT ARE THE COSTS OF A DUI ARREST?” If you have been arrested for driving under the influ- ence,youhaveprobablyrealizedthatthecostsof aDUI arrestaregreat,bothemotionallyandfinancially.
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC essary. An ignition interlock device is basically a breathalyzer that is put in the steering column of your car. Unless it shows that your blood alcohol content (BAC) is belo
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth pensive, as you would probably guess. Because this kind of insurance is a tell tale sign of a DUI, some insurance companies will refuse to insure you in the
CHAPTER THREE “HOW DO I AVOID BEING STOPPED BY THE POLICE?” There are preventative steps you can take to avoid being pulled over in the first place.Many of these steps will help you avoid making the
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC just grip the steering wheel and put your foot on the brake.Also make sure that the seat and steering wheel are adjusted properly for you. Taking a few seconds to do this is
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth KnowWhereNotToGo—AvoidSobrietyCheckpoints Keep alert to sobriety checkpoints, especially during holiday periods. While the police are legally required to noti
CHAPTER FOUR “I'VE BEEN PULLED OVER BY THE POLICE – WHATSHOULDIKNOW?” Let us say you are driving down the road and you see the flashing lights behind you. The first thing to keep in mind is that,as
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC police officer the necessary reasonable suspicion to pull you over legally for driving under the influence. The most common ones are listed below. · Driving on or over the l
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth viding a non-alcohol related explanation for your driving—while it will not help you while you are on the road with the officer—may be crucial in your crimin
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC If he suspects that you were driving while intoxicated, the officer will be looking for sufficient reason to ar- rest you.From the moment he lays eyes on you he will observe
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth “I'vebeenaskedtogetoutofthecar—doIhaveto?” If the officer asks you to get out of the car, you must do so or you will be arrested. If the officer pats you down
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC ficer asks you to do—is to say,“I'd like to speak to an attorney first.” If you decide to submit to a field sobriety test,the of- ficer will ask you to do one or several of
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth same number of heel-to-toe steps back.You may“fail” this test if you begin too early, step off the line, lose your balance,lose count of how many steps you t
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC driving while intoxicated.At this point he has proba- bly already decided to arrest you.It might surprise you that most people,sober or otherwise,“fail”these tests. There ar
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth PreliminaryBreathTests The other test that you may be asked to take is a pre- liminary alcohol screening device test (PBT).Just like the field sobriety test,
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC Once you are arrested, the officer may provide you with a Miranda advisory.A Miranda warning—which most of us know from movies and television—advises individuals of their con
CHAPTER FIVE “THE GUILT MYTH”— FIELD SOBRIETY TESTS, SLURRED SPEECH & ROADSIDE BREATH TESTS Police officers give a number of reasons for arrest- ing someone for a DUI. Three of the most com- mon ar
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC However, this still introduces bias into a process that should be as objective as possible. In spite of this bias, we would still hope that the offi- cer has been trained to
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth local police officers were shown videotapes of 21 sub- jects taking six common field sobriety tests and were asked to decide which were too intoxicated to dr
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC Okay, so police officers are not well trained in assess- ing the results of field sobriety tests. Would more training help? Can anybody make fairly reliable judg- ments based
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth actual studies that yielded these results paints a very different picture.A few researchers obtained their data and experimental design through the Freedom o
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC SlurredSpeech There is also a good chance that,in addition to show- ing that you“failed”field sobriety tests, the police re- port also notes that you were slurring your speech
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth someone who consumed alcohol but can nonetheless drive legally, based only on how they talk? To that question the answer is decidedly“No.”Studies have shown
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC TheRoadsideBreathTest The portable breathalyzer, which is used on the road- side, and the somewhat more sophisticated breath- test machine at the police station, are both subj
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth Following these instructions will ensure that the ma- chine is exposed to the alcohol-rich blood from the damp air portion of your lungs.It is staggering to
CHAPTER SIX “I'VE BEEN STOPPED AT ASOBRIETYCHECKPOINT — HOW DOES THIS WORK?” While most DUI stops are made by individual officers on the road, there may be times when you encounter a sobriety checkp
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC the breath, slurred speech, glassy eyes, etc. If you do not show any of these signs, you must be allowed to drive on. If the officer does decide that you display signs of imp
CHAPTER SEVEN “I'VE BEEN ARRESTED AND TAKEN TO THE POLICE STATION – WHAT HAPPENS NOW?” You have been arrested. Your car has been towed away, or driven home by a passenger or other person who the of
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC The primary reason why you have been taken to the police station is for you to take a more“scientific”test of your blood alcohol level, one that can be used as evidence in co
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth time. The fact of your refusal can also be a damaging piece of evidence at trial. That being said, it is up to you to weigh the potential negative consequenc
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC curate test to prove it. If, on the other hand, you be- lieve it is likely that your blood alcohol is above the legal limit, the urinalysis test would be the most eas- ily at
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth arrest—where anything you say might be used against you—you should not say anything without a lawyer present or until you have talked to a lawyer. Within a
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC of lowering your bail or being released on your own recognizance instead. If the judge decides not to release you, you must be taken before the Judge on the next available C
CHAPTER EIGHT “THE GUILT MYTH”— BREATHALYZERS Thebreathtestisthemostcommontestthatpeopleare asked to take once they are taken to the police station, but it is also highly susceptible to error.If the
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC it will absorb alcohol and inflate the test result,as will any blood that is present in the mouth at the time the test is taken. Belching,HiccuppingorVomitingPriortoaTest T
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth People with GERD, or who are experiencing symp- toms of acid reflux,are very susceptible to false results on a breath test. The reason for this is that all e
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC Back to Gerd. Breath test machines have no way to distinguish ethanol coming from the lungs from ethanol in gas form coming from the stomach. Ethanol from the stomach is more
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth testing all advocate a fifteen to twenty minute wait be- tween samples. That is because mouth alcohol will not evaporate in just two to three minutes. How d
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC machine, air and gas from the esophagus are expelled along with the lung air. This combination of lung air and ethanol gas from the esophagus is what causes el- evated readin
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth HowFastYourBodyEliminatestheAlcohol Everyone has a different metabolism, but the breath test assumes that everyone is the same. This means that a person whose
CHAPTER NINE “I NEED TO CHOOSE A LAWYER WHATQUESTIONSSHOULDIASK?” So now you have been released. Do not wait. Now is the time to hire a lawyer who can guide you through the complex and ever changing
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC resume, even if he or she has argued cases before the Supreme Court, there is no substitute for expertise in DUI law and experience defending clients who have been arrested f
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth Myth#5:“AlllawyerscarryMalpracticeInsurance.” Malpractice Insurance is not required of attorneys in Virginia.This means that if your lawyer does not carry thi
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC Is that the way you want to decide who is going to pro- tect you and your family? Eventually you will want to speak with a number of at- torneys who might represent you.This
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth ·“Doyouhaverealexperiencehandlingacaselikemine?” Youdonotwantalawyerwhoseesyourcaseasanewex- periencethatheorshewouldliketotry.Youwantsome- one with the exper
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC ·“HaveyoueverbeendisciplinedbytheStateBar?” You do not want a lawyer with a long disciplinary rap sheet and you deserve to know if your lawyer has been disciplined in the past
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth ·“Whatwillbethefinaloutcomeofmycase?” A good attorney will not promise you a specific result, because it is always impossible to be certain how a case will tu
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC crease your chances of being convicted.But no matter what,having found an experienced attorney to repre- sent you,you should rest assured that you are well pre- pared for the
CHAPTER TEN “MY CASE IS GOING TO TRIAL— HOW DO I PREPARE? “ You do not have to know everything about the trial process and how to argue your case—that is what an attorney is for. This chapter is sim
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC certain action.There are several different types of mo- tions, each with a different goal.Filing successful mo- tions, no matter what the specific type, will help you and you
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth saw. This means that an anonymous tip would not be enough. If this motion is successful, all the evidence obtained by pulling you over (which is nearly every
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC vestigation, results of scientific tests, and all written or recorded statements of witnesses whom the prose- cutor intends to call at a prospective trial. However, if eithe
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth attorney will offer a plea deal that you will consider with your attorney.If you choose to take the prosecu- tor's offer, or to have your attorney counter wi
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC jail,as well as any expert witnesses who will testify re- garding medical issues,field sobriety tests,breath tests, or other issues. You may also testify if you and your lawy
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth fully, the prosecutors must present theirs. In a jury trial, the prosecution always presents its case first. In a certain way,this works in your favor becaus
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC your behalf. If you performed reasonably well on the field sobriety tests—displaying good balance, coordi- nation, attention and reasoning—the expert can use your performance
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth the accident based on facts in the case. The accident reconstruction expert can testify regarding the me- chanics of the accident, and give his or her opinio
CHAPTER ELEVEN “THE GUILT MYTH”— BAC LEVEL At trial,one of the most important pieces of evidence against you is the chemical test that you took at the police station. But consider for a moment that
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC tially from the norm. We don't need a study to tell us this. Every one of us has a friend who can eat twice what we can and still stay thin, or a friend who eats half what we
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth In response to these difficult issues of proof, many states have tried to simplify matters by passing laws governing how the chemical tests should be inter-
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC These kinds of laws have been ultimately responsible for countless DUI convictions.Faith in the unreliable and error-prone methods of breath testing and retro- grade extrapol
CHAPTER TWELVE “WHAT DO I NEED TO KNOW ABOUTTHELAWINMYSTATE?” —DUILAWINVIRGINIA DifferencesinDUILawinVirginiafromOtherStates TheVirginia legal system for DUI's has several notable differences from
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC In Virginia, there is no difference between DUI and DWI. Virginia Code Section 18.2-266 makes it illegal to drive while intoxicated or under the influence of alcohol and/or
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth ecutionof one'scase. One wayof provingDUI,known as the“per se”law, looks at nothing but the breath re- sult. If it is .08 or above, the person is presumed to
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC BAC while driving was below a .08 or that the results should not be given much weight because of issues with the machine or manner of testing. If the defen- dant is able to d
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth of DUI.) Or, to use a golf analogy,Virginia allows all DUI clients a“Mulligan”on their first DUI trial! Thetrialcourtsruleonbothfines,jailtimeandlicensesus-
Virginia DUI Penalties Caution: DUI Laws change every year. This is the law as of July 2007. Check with an at- torney before relying on this book for the current status of the law. AdministrativeL
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC First Offense - Penalties i) BAC < .15 Class 1 misdemeanor (Up to $2,500 fine and 12 months in jail) with a mandatory minimum fine of $250. ii)
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth jail sentence. · If the BAC was between .15 and .20, ad- ditional 10 days mandatory minimum jail sentence. · If the BAC was greater than .20, addi
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC after 4 months. Ignition Interlock re- quired for Restricted OL. Third Offense - Penalties A) All 3 committed within 5 years period · Class 6 FELONY: 1-5 years imprison
VirginiaDUIPenaltyChartasofJuly2007 OFFENSE BLOOD ALCOHOL LEVEL JailorPrison Sentence Fine VehicleInter- lock18.2– 270.1 License Suspension 46.2–391 Vehicle Forfeitur
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC TransportingChildrenWhileUndertheInfluence Conviction of any DUI offense involving a juvenile passenger (age 17 or younger) in the vehicle at the time of the offense carries a
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth and driving,substance abuse and health,and self-eval- uation of potential for substance abuse. IgnitionInterlockProgram Virginia requires that anyone convi
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC or safety action program; (iii) travel during the hours of such person's employment if the operation of a motor vehicle is a necessary incident of such employ- ment; (iv) tra
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth The court shall order the surrender of such person's li- cense to operate a motor vehicle and shall forward to the Commissioner of the Department of MotorVeh
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC No Immediate Restricted License If Prior DUI Convictions · No restricted license shall be issued during the first four months of a revocation for a second-
CHAPTER THIRTEEN 8 Secrets Your Prosecutor May Not Want You To Know About Your Virginia DUI 1. If everyone insists on his constitutional right to go to trial, the prosecutor will be
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC be prosecuting their felony cases than handling a traffic court docket.Furthermore,the prosecutors have 20 to 30 other cases with attorneys on the trafficcourtdocketthattheym
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth usual for an officer to have 5 to 10 DUI cases on one date in addition to dozens of other traffic tickets. The officer often has little, if any, recol- lecti
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC testing is concerned, the prosecutors would rather, and shamefully so, hide their head in the sand than understand the technical, medical and scientific reasons why a tes
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth the manual states that the walk-and-turn test “requires a line that the suspect can see.” These instructions are rarely followed. 8. The breath testing equ
CHAPTER FOURTEEN 20 Ways Lawyers who are “Asleep at the Wheel” of Your Virginia DUI Trial can LOSE Winnable Cases! There is one certainty at a DUI trial - the DUI defen- dant cannot prevail on an is
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC idence regarding the results of field sobriety tests or breath tests. INVALIDSTOP 1. The arresting officer did not have “reasonable suspicion” for the stop. The United Sta
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth SUVs on the road, what an officer describes as weaving within the lane could merely be a matter of observing the vehicle move a matter of inches from the mid
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC INVALIDARRESTDEFENSES 5. The officer did not have probable cause to make an arrest. The major difference between“chal- lenges to the arrest” and “challenges to the stop” is t
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth pointed out to the judge that he or she must consider that, if this were a civil case and the prosecution pre- sented the evidence that they did of everythin
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC an alcoholic beverage does not provide any indication of the amount of alcohol consumed. 8. Bloodshot and glassy eyes. The officer will have to admit that they do not know w
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth be asked whether the client slurred every word or just some words. Very often, the only slurring was the client rapidly saying the letters LMNOP while reciti
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC (HGN) of the time. For example, the one leg stand was found to correctly predict a BAC of .10% or higher in only 65% of those tested. 13. Failure to object to admissibility
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth According to NHTSA, normal, sober people have a nystagmus at high peripheral angles ( i.e. when they are looking to the extreme left or right).However,the st
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC remedies can cause nystagmus.Also,how can an offi- cer accurately tell a 45° angle? The officer almost al- ways testifies that the client is unsteady on his feet and swaying,
DUI/DWIArrestSurvivalGuide:TheGuiltMyth that the burden of proof for the admissibility of the scientific evidence was on the prosecution. Again, I have yet to see an officer who can testify about t
MichaelC.Tillotson,LLC that he had not been consuming alcohol after getting into the accident and exiting the vehicle. By statute, the officer must arrest the suspect within three hours of the driv
FOOTNOTES 1 Driving Under the Influence (DUI) and Driving While Intoxicated (DWI) are only two common names given for the crime of operating a motor vehi- cle while intoxicated.From this point forwa
Zmags improved online publishingTheDUIMythBook
\n');
}
function onAppLoad() {
}
function onControlPanelLoad(name) {
}
function onPageLoad(pageid) {
}
function onZoomPageLoad(pageid) {
}
function onZoom(pageid, x, y) {
}
function onZoomOut(pageid) {
}
function onPageFlip(pageid, direction) {
}
function onCrop(pageid, x, y, height, width) {
}
function onTipFriend(pageid, friendmail, usermail) {
}
function onPrint(pageList) {
}
function onGetPDF() {
}
function onLinkClick(type, pageid, infoObject) {
}
This publication requires version 8 of the Flash Player It appears that you do not have Flash Player 8 installed.
Please Click Here
to download the Flash plugin.